Found an interesting list compiled by Dr. Lisa Newman, N.D., Ph.D., Mike Adams, and the non-profit Consumer Wellness Center. I’ll only list the 4-Star and 5-Star ingredients; these would be GREAT in your furry family’s food.
Reviewing the list, clearly Dr. Newman is speaking from a human nutrition standpoint because, while she speaks authoritatively on the general quality and nutrient value of an ingredient, she is not a veterinarian and can’t speak to the dietary needs of pets. For example, she lists “whole wheat” and “corn” as 5-Star ingredients when wheat and corn are widely known to be top allergens in dogs and when they are understood by holistic vets to be mostly a cheap and poorly digestible protein source.
Nevertheless, what she had to say about ingredients, in general, is worth reading.
carrots (5 stars) found in 12% of pet food products analyzed
Natural source of beta carotene (precursor to Vitamin A needed for immune function), excellent fiber.
cracked pearled barley (5 stars) found in 3% of pet food products analyzed
A nutritive, wonderful grain.
cracked barley (5 stars) found in 2% of pet food products analyzed
A nutritive, wonderful grain.
garlic oil (5 stars) found in 6% of pet food products analyzed
Excellent antioxidant, antibiotic.
– Note: AAFCO guidelines limit the amount of garlic that can be included in pet formulations because it can lead to Heinz anemia in dogs and cats. Nevertheless, in small quantities, it is an excellent nutrient and also a natural flea control.
lamb stock (5 stars) found in 2% of pet food products analyzed
More nutritious than simple water used for processing can foods, flavoring in dry food.
copper proteinate (5 stars) found in 23% of pet food products analyzed
Best source of copper used, aids in bone formation, iron absorption, protein metabolism, bone formation
ground whole grain sorghum (5 stars) found in 9% of pet food products analyzed
Cousin to millet, very nutritive grain, alkalizing to the body, easy to digest.
– Sorry, we have to disagree with Dr. Newman. In pet foods, sorghum is a cheap protein source, poorly digestible.
ground whole grain corn (5 stars) found in 6% of pet food products analyzed
Contains all nutrients/protein of corn.
– Sorry, we have to disagree with Dr. Newman. In pet foods, corn is a cheap protein source, poorly digestible.
cobalt proteinate (source of chelated cobalt) (5 stars) found in 3% of pet food products analyzed
Excellent source of cobalt, improves use, needed for B12 synthesis.
rosemary extract and citric acid (5 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Natural preservatives – citric acid is Vitamin C.
venison meal (5 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Excellent alternative to standard meats, in concentrated form for more protein pound for pound.
chicken broth (5 stars) found in 17% of pet food products analyzed
Source of flavor, excellent if used instead of plain water for processing can food.
peas (5 stars) found in 7% of pet food products analyzed
Excellent source of protein/carbohydrates/fiber.
canola oil (preserved with mixed tocopherols) (5 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Excellent source of fat for energy, high in omega-3 fatty acids, natural Vitamin E preservative.
canola oil (5 stars) found in 5% of pet food products analyzed
Excellent source of fat for energy and healthy coat contains 10% omega 3 fatty acids and half the saturated fat found in other vegetable oils commonly used in pet food.
calcium ascorbate (5 stars) found in 3% of pet food products analyzed
Buffered source of Vitamin C.
garlic extract (5 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Concentrated form has more health benefits unless listed at bottom of label which indicates a token use.
– Note: AAFCO guidelines limit the amount of garlic that can be included in pet formulations because it can lead to Heinz anemia in dogs and cats. Nevertheless, in small quantities, it is an excellent nutrient and also a natural flea control.
borage oil (5 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Excellent source of Omega-3 fatty acids.
trace minerals (zinc proteinate) (5 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Best form of zinc, protects against cell damage and stimulates immune system, but indicates lack of well-rounded supplementation.
turkey broth (5 stars) found in 3% of pet food products analyzed
Used instead of plain water for processing, more nutritional, flavor enhancing in dry foods.
beef meal (5 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Dehydrated whole muscle meat, packs more protein pound for pound.
beef broth (5 stars) found in 6% of pet food products analyzed
Used instead of plain water in can foods or as flavoring in dry foods.
chicken meal (5 stars) found in 17% of pet food products analyzed
Concentrated chicken meat, more protein since water weight has been removed. Excellent source of protein for cats, good source for dogs.
mixed tocopherols (a source of natural vitamin E) (5 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Superior source of natural Vitamin E oils.
lamb broth (5 stars) found in 4% of pet food products analyzed
Used instead of plain water in can foods, as flavoring in dry foods.
lamb meal (5 stars) found in 10% of pet food products analyzed
Excellent protein source, concentrated-more protein for the money. Less likely to cause allergies, easy to digest.
lecithin (5 stars) found in 7% of pet food products analyzed
A natural antioxidant, very beneficial.
dried peas (5 stars) found in 2% of pet food products analyzed
Source of protein/carbohydrates/fiber.
mackerel (5 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Good source of cold water fish, high in fatty acids.
iron proteinate (5 stars) found in 6% of pet food products analyzed
Excellent, most expensive source of iron needed for red blood cell reproduction.
manganese proteinate (5 stars) found in 13% of pet food products analyzed
Best source of manganese, necessary to development of strong bones and enzyme activators, enhances immune system.
manganous proteinate (5 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Excellent source of manganese, nourishes the nerves and brain. Supports immune and enzyme functions.
dried garlic (5 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Excellent antioxidant, antibiotic, flea and tick repellent if listed high on the label.
– Note: AAFCO guidelines limit the amount of garlic that can be included in pet formulations because it can lead to Heinz anemia in dogs and cats. Nevertheless, in small quantities, it is an excellent nutrient and also a natural flea control.
flax seed (5 stars) found in 8% of pet food products analyzed
Whole seeds provide best omega-3 fatty acids and nutritive fiber.
menhaden fish oil (5 stars) found in 3% of pet food products analyzed
Excellent source of fatty acids.
dehydrated carrots (5 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Provides good source of nutritional fiber.
herring oil (5 stars) found in 2% of pet food products analyzed
Excellent source of fatty acids.
halibut (5 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Excellent source of protein, fatty acids.
oat bran (5 stars) found in 2% of pet food products analyzed
Aids stool regulation, nutritive fiber.
oat groats (5 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Oats are very beneficial grains, groat simply has outer fibrous shell off.
oat meal (5 stars) found in 10% of pet food products analyzed
Crushed oat groats, nutritive fiber, good for colon health, balances body’s pH, aids colon health.
ocean fish (5 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Quality cold water fish, highly nutritious, high in fatty acids.
ocean whitefish (5 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Excellent source of protein, fatty acids.
dried carrots (5 stars) found in 4% of pet food products analyzed
Good source of nutrients and fiber.
dried apples (5 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Provides good source of nutritional fiber.
ground whole grain barley (5 stars) found in 4% of pet food products analyzed
Excellent source of nutrients and dietary fiber is low gluten grain, non-allergenic.
menhaden fish meal (5 stars) found in 2% of pet food products analyzed
Excellent source of fish, highly concentrated source of protein and good source of fatty acids..
whole ground wheat (5 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Is whole ground, very nutritive grain, source of protein, dietary fiber.
– Sorry, we have to disagree with Dr. Newman. In pet foods, wheat is a cheap protein source, poorly digestible.
zinc proteinate (5 stars) found in 13% of pet food products analyzed
Best source of zinc, protects against free radicals, essential to insulin formation and immune function.
whole sweet potatoes (5 stars) found in 3% of pet food products analyzed
Nutritive carbohydrates, natural sugars promote energy not hyperactivity.
whole ground brown rice (5 stars) found in 3% of pet food products analyzed
Is whole ground, very nutritive grain, source of protein, dietary fiber.
whole ground oats (5 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Excellent grain source, easy on the digestive tract.
whole brown rice (5 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Whole grain, nutritive.
– Often used as a binder in holistic foods. Note we said BINDER, not filler, needed to hold the kibble together.
garlic powder (5 stars) found in 4% of pet food products analyzed
Excellent antioxidant and antibiotic, more concentrated than plain garlic.
– Note: AAFCO guidelines limit the amount of garlic that can be included in pet formulations because it can lead to Heinz anemia in dogs and cats. Nevertheless, in small quantities, it is an excellent nutrient and also a natural flea control.
alpha-lipoic acid (5 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Added for healthy skin and coat.
whole ground barley (5 stars) found in 4% of pet food products analyzed
Excellent source of nutrients and dietary fiber, is low gluten grain, non-allergenic source of protein.
rosemary extract (5 stars) found in 22% of pet food products analyzed
Natural preservative, concentrated.
whole carrots (5 stars) found in 3% of pet food products analyzed
Good source of beta carotene, nutrients and fiber.
catfish meal (4 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Good source of protein, fatty acids but some of the natural oils are lost.
catfish (4 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Good source of protein, fatty acids.
alfalfa dehydrated meal (4 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Excellent source of chlorophyll.
alfalfa concentrate powder (4 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Excellent source of chlorophyll.
sun-cured alfafa meal (4 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Alfalfa meal provides chlorophyll but “sun-cured” a bit gimmicky.
iron amino acid chelate (4 stars) found in 5% of pet food products analyzed
Better source of iron, improves use, needed for red blood cell production.
white fish (4 stars) found in 3% of pet food products analyzed
Alternative source of protein.
cod (4 stars) found in 4% of pet food products analyzed
Good protein alternative.
whitefish (4 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Good alternative to standard meats.
whole wheat (4 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Nutritionally complete grain, good source of grain protein but often suspected to cause allergies.
– Sorry, we have to disagree with Dr. Newman. In pet foods, wheat is a cheap protein source, poorly digestible.
copper amino acid chelate (4 stars) found in 5% of pet food products analyzed
Better source of copper, improves use, needed for iron absorption, bone formation, protein metabolism and blood clotting.
cobalt amino acid chelate (4 stars) found in 5% of pet food products analyzed
Better source of cobalt, improves use, needed for B12 synthesis.
citric acid and rosemary (4 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Natural preservatives although citric acid (Vitamin C) can be harsh on digestive tract.
chicken liver, fresh (4 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Indicates better quality, but can be misleading.
chicken stock (4 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Better than plain water used for processing canned foods or flavoring dry foods.
oats (4 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Good source of fiber and energy but not whole ground for full nutritional value.
chicory extract (4 stars) found in 3% of pet food products analyzed
Concentrated source of innulin, a prebiotic, gimmicky but more effective than plain root or powders.
chicken fat (naturally preserved with mixed tocopherols) (4 stars) found in 19% of pet food products analyzed
Good source of energy and flavor, preserved with Vitamin E, but dogs do better with vegetable and fish oils.
shrimp (4 stars) found in 2% of pet food products analyzed
Good source of protein.
rosemary (4 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Natural preservative.
ocean fish meal (4 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Concentrated cold water fish, highly nutritious, may have oils expressed leaving it lower in fatty acids.
folic acid supplement (4 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Standard source, needed for blood building and DNA synthesis.
preserved with mixed tocopherols (4 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Natural Vitamin E preservative.
citric acid and rosemary extract (4 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Common natural preservatives.
herring meal (4 stars) found in 2% of pet food products analyzed
Excellent source of protein, poor source of fatty acids as oil is pressed out of fish to make meal.
sage (4 stars) found in 5% of pet food products analyzed
Natural preservative.
green beans (4 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Good source of nutrients and fiber.
alfalfa nutrient concentrate (4 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Good source of chlorophyll, protein and nutrients.
chicken fat (4 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Good source of energy for cats, dogs do best on oils rather than animal fat.
venison stock (4 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Better than plain water for processing in can foods, flavor additive in dry foods.
venison (4 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Good alternative to standard meats.
duck (4 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Good alternative protein source, less heavy in water weight than chicken.
veal broth (4 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Better than simple water for processing in can, used as flavoring in dry foods.
turkey stock (4 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Better than simple water for processing in can, used as flavoring in dry foods.
beta carotene (4 stars) found in 23% of pet food products analyzed
Source of Vitamin A precursor, aids immune response, allergy control, slows aging.
dried kelp meal (4 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Good source of iodine for thyroid function and chlorophyll.
ground whole wheat (4 stars) found in 3% of pet food products analyzed
Whole ground is excellent, but not considered the best grain choice for dogs.
– Sorry, we have to disagree with Dr. Newman. In pet foods, wheat is a cheap protein source, poorly digestible.
manganese sulfate (4 stars) found in 37% of pet food products analyzed
Better source, manganese is necessary to development of strong bones and enzyme activators, enhances immune system.
venison meat (4 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Good alternative to standard meats.
ground whole peas (4 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Good source of nutrients and fiber.
tuna (4 stars) found in 4% of pet food products analyzed
Good source of protein and fatty acids.
pea fiber (4 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Good source of nutritious fiber.
pearled barley (4 stars) found in 3% of pet food products analyzed
Not whole ground, less nutritive but a wonderful grain, low gluten and flavorful.
rabbit (4 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Good alternative meat source.
copper amino acid complex (source of chelated copper) (4 stars) found in 5% of pet food products analyzed
Better source of copper, improves use, needed for iron absorption, bone formation, protein metabolism, blood clotting.
whitefish meal (4 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Good alternative to standard meats in concentrated form for more protein, can have oils expressed.
manganese amino acid chelate (4 stars) found in 10% of pet food products analyzed
Better source of manganese necessary to development of strong bones and enzyme activators, enhances immune system.
pea protein (4 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Good source of vegetable protein.
rabbit stock (4 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Better than plain water for processing in can food.
ginger extract (4 stars) found in 1% of pet food products analyzed
Good for digestion if listed high on label, if not, gimmicky.
potassium amino acid complex (source of chelated potassium) (4 stars) found in 3% of pet food products analyzed
Better source of potassium, balances acid/alkaline balance.
eggs (4 stars) found in 4% of pet food products analyzed
Good source of protein, free of shell.
garlic (4 stars) found in 5% of pet food products analyzed
Good antioxidant, antibiotic. IS SAFE TO USE!
– Note: AAFCO guidelines limit the amount of garlic that can be included in pet formulations because it can lead to Heinz anemia in dogs and cats. Nevertheless, in small quantities, it is an excellent nutrient and also a natural flea control.
yucca schidigera extract (4 stars) found in 3% of pet food products analyzed
Used to reduce stool odor, concentrated.
zinc amino acid chelate (4 stars) found in 5% of pet food products analyzed
Better source of zinc, improves use, protects against free radicals, essential to insulin formation and immune function.
Filed under: Ingredients | Comments Off